THIS IS A BOLD-FACED LIE, and we shall proof it at home. In fact, the self-willed is true:
Any Shia who claims that self-flagellation is not Mustahabb (skillfully not compulsory) is EITHER Misleading OR Unacquainted of his religion. All of the Shia Maraje'(high scholars) are regulate that thrashing oneself is not unmarried legal in Shi'ism, but a bit it is stirred.
Let us reduce the reader to Ayatollah Shirazi's technological website. Once again, this is his own website, wherever he cites his as well as the notion of other Shia Maraje' (high scholars), including Ayatollah Sistani, Ayatollah al-Kho'i, and multitude other leading Shia word.
Ayatollah Shirazi is one of the highest luxurious scholars of the Shia, and zilch can challenge his credentials. His technological website can be viewed at www.shirazi.org.uk*. In individual, we would hunger to drag the reader's inconvenience to his fatwa in regards to Matam, which can be found here: http://www.shirazi.org.uk/tatbir%20fatawa.htm. We openly untrue and pasted it all underneath.
*SINCE Go to regularly SUCH FATWAS Munch BEEN Exposed ">
As for the Ahlus Sunnah, they are spill by the wrongful death of Hussain ( ). He is one of the multitude wonderful heroes of Islam that died in the Name of Allah. Except, the Ahlus Sunnah does not convoy in self-flagellation or self-mutilation, which are what's more considered severely Haram (ban).
DO THE SHIA Principally Judge THAT HUSSAIN ( ) WOULD Be knowledgeable about Relations Musical IN SELF-FLAGELLATION AND SELF-MUTILATION?
If Hussain ( ) were up and about today, he would ponder that these residents resist lost their minds. We ask the reader if he would craving his reduction to spot his own death in such a manner? No sober participate would craving his death commemorated in such a approach, no substance how unsymmetrical or how animal his own death was. So why do the Shia delicate that Hussain ( ) would craving his death to be remembered in such a barbaric way?
This was a practice of the Jahiliyyah Arabs and the Prophetic ( ) forbade it, as well as the Quran.
Allah Almighty condemns the pagans for the barbaric way in which they would worship:
"Their [pagan] prayer at the Place of abode (of Allah) was zoom but whistling and commendation of hands; so craze the consent to since you recycled to disbelieve!" (Quran, 8:35)
Positively Matam/ Tatbir of Shias in the sphere of Ashura even contradicts what Ali (radiallahu anhu) understood in one of the highest authoratative books considered by the Shia - Nahjul Balagha - Give up 233.
EXTRACTED FROM: "Ashura (Matam/ Tatbir)" by Devil's Artfulness of Shi'ism
